I've already had this beer. Technically, I had a 2016 version of this beer. In fact, the 2016 version of this beer was the first barrel aged beer that I had that really allowed me to understand what this type of beer brings to the table. Previous to this, I encountered a few beers that were barrel aged, and all I could think of was that this style of maturing a beer was antithetical to everything I looked for in a beer. It took what is a delightful beer style (in this case a stout) and subjected it to heavy liquors and old wood to alter the taste beyond that of what is beer. Since then, I hope I have matured. This 2020 vintage is, I understand, very different from the previous version - as am I.
Out of sheer habit, I started pouring the beer as if it may have head coming out. Then, I transitioned quickly to a straight pour, and still there is virtually no head coming out to play. The resulting black liquid reminds me more of motor oil than the beer that was actually named after it. The aroma is absolutely scrumptious with smoke, vanilla, and brown sugar all waiting to be consumed with fury. And I am game.
First sip is wood, smoke, vanilla, and charred brown sugar. It reminds me of the first time I had one of these and my eyes opened to what they were all about and what they could bring to the table. I would say that since then, I have gotten a significant amount of respect and experience with these beers. I’m trying not to let packaging impact my judgment, but this sips like a damn good beer.
Tip-in is solid, heavy, and sweet with caramel, brown sugar, and smoke weighing down the mouth while very, very light carbonation tingles ever so slightly. The middle is pronounced with an alcohol-laden smoked wood, vanilla, and a tight but relaxed mix of the flavors in the tip-in. The finish scoffs at my assertion that the alcohol lived in the middle by becoming more pronounced as the wood takes over with a dryness in tow before a wave of sweet syrup descends for the trail-off.
Bottom Line: I don’t know that there is a whole lot of room above this in the hierarchy.
4.75/5